Philosopher's Stone
Some card images may not be available for public viewing.

Philosopher's Stone (Alchemy)

Cost: $3

Type: Treasure

Text: When you play this, count your deck and discard pile. Worth $1 per 5 cards total between them (rounded down).

Strategy Review

Here's a comprehensive strategy guide for Philosopher's Stone:

Philosopher's Stone Strategy Guide

Introduction Philosopher's Stone is one of the most unique treasure cards in Dominion, as its value scales with the total number of cards in your deck and discard pile. Unlike most treasures which have a fixed value, Philosopher's Stone's value can range from $0 to potentially $4 or more in a single play. Understanding how to maximize its potential while avoiding its pitfalls is crucial for success.

Basic Mechanics - Philosopher's Stone counts both your deck and discard pile when determining its value - The count happens when you play it, not when you buy it - The value is rounded down (24 cards = 4 value, 25 cards = 5 value) - Multiple Philosopher's Stones each count separately when played - Cards in your hand or in play are not counted

Core Strategy Considerations

  1. Deck Size Management The primary factor in Philosopher's Stone's effectiveness is the total number of cards in your deck and discard pile. Here's how many cards you need for different values:
  2. 0-4 cards = $0
  3. 5-9 cards = $1
  4. 10-14 cards = $2
  5. 15-19 cards = $3
  6. 20-24 cards = $4
  7. 25-29 cards = $5 And so on...

A typical starting deck (7 Coppers, 3 Estates) will make Philosopher's Stone worth $2. This means it's already comparable to Silver from the start, making it a reasonable early-game purchase.

  1. Timing Considerations The timing of when you play Philosopher's Stone in your turn matters significantly:
  2. Playing it early in your turn means more cards in your deck
  3. Playing it late means more cards in your discard pile

  4. If you have multiple Philosopher's Stones, play them before drawing more cards or shuffling

  5. Card Draw Interaction Card draw affects Philosopher's Stone in complex ways: Advantages:

  6. Helps you find your Philosopher's Stones more consistently
  7. Can increase deck size through gained cards

Disadvantages: - Moves cards from your deck to your hand (where they don't count) - Can create situations where you draw your deck and have few cards left to count

Optimal Strategy Elements

  1. Early Game (Turns 1-4)
  2. Philosopher's Stone is a viable opening at $3
  3. Consider opening Philosopher's Stone/Silver for reliable early money
  4. Avoid early trashing unless you have a specific strategy

  5. Build deck size through gainers or cheap cards

  6. Mid Game (Turns 5-10)

  7. Focus on increasing deck size strategically
  8. Consider whether to invest in additional Philosopher's Stones
  9. Balance deck-building with maintaining valuable cards

  10. Watch your deck-discard ratio when playing treasures

  11. Late Game (Turns 11+)

  12. Be aware of how greening affects Philosopher's Stone's value
  13. Consider timing shuffles to maximize value
  14. May need to transition away from Philosopher's Stone if deck gets too thin

Synergistic Cards and Combinations

Strong Synergies:

  1. Gainers
  2. Workshop: Helps build deck size efficiently
  3. Bureaucrat: Adds cards while potentially helping with deck management
  4. Border Village: Adds multiple cards at once

  5. Tragic Hero: Mass gaining helps boost Stone's value

  6. Card-Adding Effects

  7. Archive: Keeps cards in your deck while providing draw
  8. Haven: Sets aside cards that would otherwise not count
  9. Scheme: Helps maintain deck size by recycling cards

  10. Gardens: Natural combo as both benefit from large decks

  11. Deck Management

  12. Warehouse: Helps manage hand size without removing cards
  13. Cellar: Can help optimize when to shuffle
  14. Royal Seal: Helps control where gained cards go
  15. Treasury: Helps maintain deck size

Anti-Synergies:

  1. Heavy Trashing
  2. Chapel: Can severely reduce Philosopher's Stone's value
  3. Steward: Similar issues to Chapel

  4. Ambassador: Removes cards from your deck

  5. Draw-to-X Cards

  6. Library: Can leave few cards in deck
  7. Watchtower: Similar to Library

  8. Jack of all Trades: Combines trashing with draw

  9. Deck Inspection

  10. Scout: Can reveal Philosopher's Stone at bad times
  11. Adventurer: Can strand Philosopher's Stone in deck

Specific Strategic Approaches

  1. The "Big Deck" Strategy Focus on:
  2. Multiple cheap cards
  3. Gainers
  4. Avoiding trashing
  5. Multiple Philosopher's Stones

Key cards: - Workshop - Gardens - Vagrant - Market Square

  1. The "Controlled Growth" Strategy Focus on:
  2. Selective gaining
  3. Deck management
  4. Balanced approach
  5. Timing shuffles

Key cards: - Merchant - Warehouse - Treasury - Hunting Grounds

  1. The "Hybrid Economy" Strategy Focus on:
  2. Mix of traditional treasure and Philosopher's Stone
  3. Flexible deck size
  4. Strategic shuffling
  5. Card draw control

Key cards: - Silver - Gold - Market - Laboratory

Counter-Strategy and Defense

When Opposing Philosopher's Stone: 1. Attack their deck size: - Use trashing attacks - Force discards - Utilize deck inspection

  1. Rush strategies:
  2. Go for provinces quickly
  3. Focus on efficiency over size

  4. Use strong money

  5. Curse giving:

  6. While curses add to deck size, they hurt overall efficiency
  7. Can make Philosopher's Stone awkward to use

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  1. Over-investing
  2. Don't buy too many Philosopher's Stones
  3. Balance with other treasures

  4. Consider diminishing returns

  5. Neglecting Deck Quality

  6. Don't add weak cards just for size
  7. Maintain some efficiency

  8. Consider victory card impact

  9. Poor Timing

  10. Playing Philosopher's Stone at wrong moments
  11. Not considering shuffle timing
  12. Mismanaging multiple Stones

Advanced Tips and Techniques

  1. Shuffle Timing
  2. Track when shuffles will occur
  3. Plan turns around optimal Stone plays

  4. Consider keeping some cards in hand

  5. Multi-Stone Management

  6. Calculate optimal play order
  7. Consider spreading Stones across shuffles

  8. Track value changes

  9. Kingdom Analysis

  10. Evaluate Stone's potential early
  11. Consider alternative strategies
  12. Watch for synergies and anti-synergies

Kingdom Considerations

When to Buy Philosopher's Stone: - No strong trashing - Gainers present - Deck-friendly kingdom - Limited alternate economy

When to Skip Philosopher's Stone: - Heavy trashing available - Strong traditional money - Draw-heavy kingdoms - Rush strategies viable

Sample Turn Examples

Example 1: Early Game Starting hand: Copper, Copper, Copper, Estate, Philosopher's Stone Play: Coppers first, then Stone (deck has 5 cards) = $4 total

Example 2: Mid Game Deck: 20 cards Discard: 5 cards Playing Stone = $5 value

Example 3: Late Game Multiple Stones with 30 card deck Play order matters significantly Consider timing with shuffles

Conclusion

Philosopher's Stone is a unique treasure that requires careful planning and strategy to use effectively. Success with this card comes from: - Understanding deck size management - Timing plays appropriately - Selecting supportive kingdom cards - Avoiding common pitfalls - Maintaining flexibility in strategy

While not always the optimal choice, in the right kingdom and with proper support, Philosopher's Stone can be a powerful economic engine that rewards careful play and strategic deck building.

Remember: - Track your deck size - Plan your shuffles - Consider kingdom synergies - Stay flexible in strategy - Practice timing optimization

With these principles in mind, Philosopher's Stone can be a valuable addition to your Dominion strategy arsenal, particularly in kingdoms that support larger deck sizes and controlled deck management.